Thomas Mesereau on Anderson Cooper 360???? (CNN) transcript:
COOPER (voice-over): A change of heart? Two jurors from the Michael
Jackson trial say Jackson was guilty and they were pressured to say
he wasn't. Tonight, Jackson's star attorney, Thomas Mesereau, speaks
out.
And decoding the mystery of dreams. Do you really just dream in
black-and-white? And what do your dreams really mean? Tonight, 360
M.D., Dr. Sanjay Gupta, reveal what's really happens inside your
sleeping mind. 360 continues.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
(COMMERCIAL BREAK)
(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)
RAY HULTMAN, JUROR IN MICHAEL JACKSON TRIAL: I don't think anybody
was really talked out of an opinion. It was more of presenting
additional information about the timing of certain events.
I mean, it's very conceivable that somebody can appear to be telling
the truth, and their demeanor would indicate that and everything
else. But, when you look at past history of the accuser, there's
some doubt. There's room for reasonable doubt.
LARRY KING, CNN HOST: And you didn't let...
HULTMAN: Really, that's what it was all about.
(END VIDEO CLIP)
COOPER: That was Ray Hultman, a juror in the Michael Jackson trial,
right after the pop star was acquitted of child molestation. Now,
eight weeks after the verdict, he's had an about-face.
Hultman and another juror, Eleanor Cook, now say they believe
Jackson was guilty and they're accusing other jurors of pressuring
them into reaching the not-guilty verdict. Joining me from
Birmingham, Alabama, to respond to the new allegations, Michael
Jackson's attorney Thomas Mesereau.
Thanks for being on the program. Do you put any stock in these
allegations?
THOMAS MESEREAU, ATTORNEY FOR MICHAEL JACKSON: I put none in them. I
think they're ridiculous. I think they're an embarrassment to the
system.
COOPER: Why do you think they're making them?
MESEREAU: I can only guess. I think, while they were on the jury,
and while they were subject to court orders, they conducted
themselves in a responsible and honorable fashion. I think they
deliberated as they were told to do, and I think they were fair,
conscientious jurors.
Now, two months have gone by since they were released from their
obligations as jurors. They've been free to talk to other people,
read whatever they want, watch whatever TV show they want. And
they've decided to write books and try and, apparently, from what
I've heard, approach movie producers.
So I have grave questions about what they're saying now.
COOPER: They both say they were suspicious of the testimony of
Debbie Rowe, Michael Jackson's ex-wife, a prosecution witness. They
say that -- or one of the guys says that he thinks she changed her
tune, and I quote, "through promises, promises that she was going to
be able to see her children more."
Were promises made to Debbie Rowe?
MESEREAU: None that I know of, and none that anybody on my team has
ever heard of. See, these people are now speculating, they're
speculating about all sorts of improprieties that they never thought
about when they were deliberating with the other jurors.
Both of them registered not guilty verdicts 14 times, not five, not
10, 14, 10 felony counts and four lesser included misdemeanor
counts. And they stated in open court to Judge Melville that this
was their verdict. So I really question what they're doing. I think
it's absurd.
COOPER: Debbie Rowe was fighting a custody battle with Michael
Jackson before the testimony. That's now been dropped. How'd that
happen?
MESEREAU: You say it's been dropped. I'm not his lawyer in that
case, and I don't know what's been dropped. I've been told there've
been settlement discussions, they've been quite amicable. And that's
the last I've heard about it.
COOPER: Do you know if they've reached a settlement?
MESEREAU: I really don't know. I know they were close to one. I knew
they were talking about one. And I think they were both operating in
a very amicable way. But I really don't know.
COOPER: When asked why these two jurors switched their votes to not
guilty, Elly Cook, one of them, basically says she was intimidated
by the foreman, Paul Rodriguez. She says that Rodriguez told her,
and I quote, "If I could not change my mind or go with a group or be
more understanding, he would have to notify the bailiff, the bailiff
would have to notify the judge, and the judge would have me
removed."
She's basically saying it was more important for her to stay on the
jury than it was to protect a child. If she really believed the
evidence showed Jackson was guilty, would there be any justification
for voting otherwise?
MESEREAU: She's not making any sense. You know, this is a mature,
frankly from what I can see, a pretty nice person. I think she's
suddenly become misguided in what she's saying or and what's she
doing.
She, again, said not guilty 14 times. She then gave some press
interviews and said she looked for the proof and couldn't find it.
She appeared on "LARRY KING" long after the verdict with the other
jurors, and they all seemed to be acting in a very cooperative,
friendly way.
All of a sudden, now while she's on the verge of writing a book,
apparently, she changes her tune. It's very suspicious and very
embarrassing. I don't think these people realize how bad they look,
because even people who were siding with the prosecution during this
trial are making fun of these two jurors.
COOPER: Well, she's apparently marketing some t-shirt with -- I
guess she's trademarked some slogan that she came up with. Her book,
I guess, is going to be called "Guilty as Sin, Free as a Bird." This
other guy has a book called "The Deliberator," I guess, coming out.
I mean, you're basically saying they're lying. Can you take action
against them? Would you?
MESEREAU: No. I have no intention of taking action against them. And
I don't know what motivates them. I don't know why, you know, two
months later, they've suddenly decided it's in their interest to run
to a lot of TV shows and go against what they said in the jury
room...
COOPER: If there's a...
MESEREAU: ... and what they said in open court.
COOPER: If there's a civil trial against Michael Jackson, do these
jurors play a role? Could they?
MESEREAU: No, no role whatsoever. Their job was done when they were
released from jury duty. For five months, they were not allowed to
talk to anyone about the case. They were not allowed to watch any TV
shows or read any books or magazines or newspapers about the case.
And approximately two months ago, all those restrictions dissolved.
They were released from jury duty. Judge Melville thanked them for
the service they had rendered, and I do think they did it honorably,
and I think they've carefully deliberated with their fellow jurors,
and with everyone in the jury room. It couldn't have been that bad
because they never complained.
COOPER: Thomas Mesereau, appreciate you joining us.
Want to take a look at what happened inside that jury room from
another perspective. Joining me by phone from Crestview, Florida,
former Jackson juror Melissa Herard. Appreciate you being with us.
Melissa, you've heard what these other two jurors were saying. Was
the -- was the -- that jury room, was it so contentious?
MELISSA HERARD, FORMER JACKSON JUROR: At some points, it was,
because they had, you know, Ray and Ellie and Kat did portray that
they did feel that Michael Jackson was guilty.
COOPER: Were they intimidated by Paul Rodriguez, the foreman?
HERARD: No, nobody was intimidated by anybody. You know, we were all
adults in there.
COOPER: Were they told that the bailiff would be called, and that
they would be thrown off the jury if they continued to say that
Jackson was guilty?
HERARD: No. What they were told is that -- that if we could not come
up with a unanimous decision and stuff, then Paul was instructed by
the judge to -- we'd have to let the bailiff know, and then the
bailiff would let the judge know that we were at a standstill,
waiting further instructions from the judge.
And they just never, you know, especially Ellie, she -- that -- I'm
so upset with them that they're doing this now. And if they felt
that strongly, then they should have, you know, stayed their stand.
But they couldn't show us. We asked them if you believe he is so
guilty, here's the room full of evidence. Would you please go in
there and show us where it shows that he's guilty? Because we went
through all of it, and not one thing pointed towards his guilt.
COOPER: Well, that's -- that's what Hultman said at the time, that
the evidence simply wasn't there. Tom Mesereau is still standing by.
Tom, you're listening in. Comments?
MESEREAU: Yes. Remember, by law, jurors have an obligation and are
ordered by the trial judge to deliberate. They must discuss the case
with their fellows jurors in a cooperative, good faith manner. And
if they refuse to, they can be thrown off the jury for not
deliberating.
So if the foreperson in this case was concerned about their refusal
to discuss or cooperate, he would have had a valid point. And
appellate courts have upheld the dismissal of jurors who refuse to
deliberate with their fellow jurors.
COOPER: Melissa, do you feel like these two jurors violated their
oath, essentially? I mean, they are claiming now that they voted
other than what they believed?
HERARD: Well, I think Ellie, from the very beginning, even before
the trial started, I think she had an agenda.
COOPER: What agenda?
HERARD: Because she -- agenda of writing a book, and everything,
because we confronted her in the jury room at the end, and we -- one
of the jurors asked her, "Ellie, are you writing a book?" And she
turned around, she said, "Well, yes, I am. I'm 79 years old and I
can do what the h I want to." And we confronted her. I said, you're
not supposed to be, you know, doing any of this stuff, you know. And
she's like, "Well, I'm not writing a book about the trial. I'm
writing a memoir on my life."
COOPER: Melissa, how many jurors are writing books? Are you writing
a book?
HERARD: No. We're not -- I haven't approached anybody, and I don't
have nothing signed. I'm waiting until after our obligation of the
90 days is over.
COOPER: Melissa Herard, appreciate you joining us. And Thomas
Mesereau, as well.
MESEREAU: I do appreciate it.
COOPER: Thanks very much.
Source: CNN