February 7, 200719 yr comment_67286 I been thinking of something. You know how alot of MJ forums such as SITE IS BLACKLISTED <-- black listed and MJNO have mods and staff but they are rude to alot of the members, etc? Well what if some how we had elections on the forum for staff members. This means each year or every so often we have staff elections and the members vote and choose the leaders. It'll work the same exact way that governments work. The members here shouldn't be afraid of the mods, but the mods should be afraid of the members, therefore there will be no power abusing. Everything will be fair, etc. I have been thinking about something like this since i started the forum in 2004, because honestly i hate when a mod is a control freak and does it just for the power, and im tired of mods on other forums getting personal and banning me for no reasons at all. haha so i think this is a good idea. i don't know how it'd work, but i think ti'd make the community alot funner and all that good stuff. So what do you think about this? And do you have any suggestions? Oh yeah there will ah vhe to be rules put in place so this wouldn't be abused either... it might not even work though so thats why i wanna discuss it. Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67294 Oh that'd be fun! I'm totally in support. Great idea. AYE! ~MC~ EDIT-You mean SITE IS BLACKLISTED? the blacklisted site? EDIT2--ooh cool! What about SITE IS BLACKLISTED? LOL EDIT3--nope. D: SITE IS BLACKLISTED and MJNO are on my blacklist. LOL. paul. hm. Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67298 Oh that'd be fun! I'm totally in support. Great idea. AYE! ~MC~ EDIT-You mean SITE IS BLACKLISTED? the blacklisted site? EDIT2--ooh cool! What about SITE IS BLACKLISTED? LOL EDIT3--nope. D: SITE IS BLACKLISTED and MJNO are on my blacklist. LOL. paul. hm. hmmmm -- some concerns. I think that on a past site I was on, that would have made it even worse than it was. Actually, now that I think about it, when the mods began running the board, it really started to fall apart. Elections mean that the staff has to be afraid to make decisions that are good for the board because they are too busy being "popular." And what if a "popular" staff member is a jerk and does a lot of things that don't work well for the board, what happens then? My two cents -- I understand what you're saying and why -- but I think there need to be a few top leaders -- and the person who runs the board should choose whomever shares their visions. Many times a popular person -- very nice and charming -- does a crappy job. I would NEVER hire my best friend -- love her to death but..... I think it's important to have respect for people who are on staff -- in whatever position -- I've been an employee and a manager in business and volunteer organizations -- appointments, in my view, are teh way to go. If people are "afraid" of mods, then they should either talk to the mod or talk to the administrator. Mods are there to keep the boards clean. If the mods or administrators are jerks, time for the member to move on. That's what I did, and it's fine -- I didn't agree with them but that's ok -- plenty of boards out there -- Just my thoughts Edited February 7, 200719 yr by justlooking2 Report
February 7, 200719 yr Author comment_67301 Oh that'd be fun! I'm totally in support. Great idea. AYE! ~MC~ EDIT-You mean EDIT2--ooh cool! What about SITE IS BLACKLISTED? LOL EDIT3--nope. D: SITE IS BLACKLISTED and MJNO are on my blacklist. LOL. paul. hm. actually that site is blacklisted, but i only entered the regular URL for it, which i'll update now. And also the one one need updating. I wish other sites would be fair so i didnt have to do this. im too lazy for it As much as alot of people dislike MJNO, i need a valid reason to blacklist them. So far they havent illegally banned me or anything yet, so i dont know of anything really that they do that we need to protect fans from. hmmmm -- some concerns. I think that on a past site I was on, that would have made it even worse than it was. Actually, now that I think about it, when the mods began running the board, it really started to fall apart. Elections mean that the staff has to be afraid to make decisions that are good for the board because they are too busy being "popular." And what if a "popular" staff member is a jerk and does a lot of things that don't work well for the board, what happens then? My two cents -- I understand what you're saying and why -- but I think there need to be a few top leaders -- and the person who runs the board should choose whomever shares their visions. Many times a popular person -- very nice and charming -- does a crappy job. I would NEVER hire my best friend -- love her to death but..... I think it's important to have respect for people who are on staff -- in whatever position -- I've been an employee and a manager in business and volunteer organizations -- appointments, in my view, are teh way to go. If people are "afraid" of mods, then they should either talk to the mod or talk to the administrator. Mods are there to keep the boards clean. If the mods or administrators are jerks, time for the member to move on. That's what I did, and it's fine -- I didn't agree with them but that's ok -- plenty of boards out there -- Just my thoughts well if someone does a crappy job they can be impeached or whatever LOL. I like the mods to give a valid reason for why they made their decisions, such as when they close a topic, i want them to reply with why they closed it, so that the member understand and doesnt get mad and leave. things like this. right now this is only an idea, and we discussed it before, but i forgot the reasons why we didnt go through with it. i have to search the board to find the old discussions about it from 2 years ago haha. Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67305 actually that site is blacklisted, but i only entered the regular URL for it, which i'll update now. And also the one one need updating. I wish other sites would be fair so i didnt have to do this. im too lazy for it As much as alot of people dislike MJNO, i need a valid reason to blacklist them. So far they havent illegally banned me or anything yet, so i dont know of anything really that they do that we need to protect fans from. well if someone does a crappy job they can be impeached or whatever LOL. I like the mods to give a valid reason for why they made their decisions, such as when they close a topic, i want them to reply with why they closed it, so that the member understand and doesnt get mad and leave. things like this. right now this is only an idea, and we discussed it before, but i forgot the reasons why we didnt go through with it. i have to search the board to find the old discussions about it from 2 years ago haha. hmmmmm -- impeached -- Yeah, I wouldn't want to be involved with something like that -- In my opinion (and obviously feel free to disagree) it just gets too messy. I can't see elections working. Just my thought Report
February 7, 200719 yr Author comment_67307 hmmmmm -- impeached -- Yeah, I wouldn't want to be involved with something like that -- In my opinion (and obviously feel free to disagree) it just gets too messy. I can't see elections working. Just my thought i dont think they'd work either, but its just an idea Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67308 That's true. Good points, Nance. Well, now I'm neutral. LOL LOL @ josh! XD As much as alot of people dislike MJNO, i need a valid reason to blacklist them. So far they havent illegally banned me or anything yet, so i dont know of anything really that they do that we need to protect fans from. Well, they banned both me and Aaron without good reason. and we all know about Paul. and if m j j f (let's see if it makes it through the censor LOL!) is blacklisted and mjno are in cahoots with them... I see enough reason. LOL I've always thought them worse than SITE IS BLACKLISTED. "Unbreakable Fanclub Aliance" Strikes me as cheesy LOL But still, up to you. I don't mind. I didn't expect any of them to have a filter like SITE IS BLACKLISTED. I love it. XD ~MC~ Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67310 Thanks Sara -- I'm sure Josh will make the right decision Just 2 cents from me -- I have SO many politics at work, I just can't stand the thought of more -- Edited February 7, 200719 yr by justlooking2 Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67313 Thanks Sara -- I'm sure Josh will make the right decision Just 2 cents from me -- I have SO many politics at work, I just can't stand the thought of more -- No, thank you! Yes, he always does! (pressure much? LOL!) Haha I can't blame you. I enjoy it, but I don't have to deal with much. XD It would get old after awhile. *hugz* ~MC~ Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67318 Honestly Josh, in my opinion.. I don't think it'd work.. It'd piss off a lot of people.. LOL But yeah, you know thats just my opinion, won't really matter. Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67384 I think it could work if we run it democratically. Meaning, we elect members we feel will do a good job--we could have topics where they could post why we should elect them, kinda like the presidential election speeches XD--and if they screw up big-time or start acting like That Site That Shall Not Be Named's mods, we can hold another election to impeach him/her and throw them out of office, and elect a runner-up mod in their place. We have kinda a checks and balances system here, meaning no mod could get away with being a douche because we have the members and the admin to make sure nothing's going on that shouldn't. And in my opinion--from personal experience--no mod should close/delete topics just because they don't like them. They moderate based on the site's rules: if a topic is within the rules, but the mod dislikes its content, they'll find a dumb reason to delete it and no one seems to care because "they're a mod, they can do anything." That shouldn't be a mindset that members have. Just my two cents. Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67395 My opinion .... if you are a good mod. then you do you're job right ! And yes there are always rules ... but if you're honest .... take the middleway .... don't be to strict with the rules... For the rest 'elections' ???? no thank you ... i don't wanna be come president and it won't work democratically ... the only thing what would happen is you will get more members who signed up just to vote for a person ... Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67411 My opinion .... if you are a good mod. then you do you're job right ! And yes there are always rules ... but if you're honest .... take the middleway .... don't be to strict with the rules... For the rest 'elections' ???? no thank you ... i don't wanna be come president and it won't work democratically ... the only thing what would happen is you will get more members who signed up just to vote for a person ... Exactly -- I mean, not to judge but that would be my fear -- Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67448 My opinion .... if you are a good mod. then you do you're job right ! And yes there are always rules ... but if you're honest .... take the middleway .... don't be to strict with the rules... For the rest 'elections' ???? no thank you ... i don't wanna be come president and it won't work democratically ... the only thing what would happen is you will get more members who signed up just to vote for a person ... If people did sign up just to vote for one person---and that person was voted for just because s/he is popular and not because of his/her moderation skills or ideals---then s/he will end up being impeached for not doing the job right. Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67449 If people did sign up just to vote for one person---and that person was voted for just because s/he is popular and not because of his/her moderation skills or ideals---then s/he will end up being impeached for not doing the job right. Maybe it's just me but I dont' want to be in the position of "impeaching" someone. That can get ugly fast and cause all kinds of hurt feelings. Not to keep repeating myself but it's too many politics for me on stuff like that. But that's just my 2 cents Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67458 Maybe it's just me but I dont' want to be in the position of "impeaching" someone. That can get ugly fast and cause all kinds of hurt feelings. Not to keep repeating myself but it's too many politics for me on stuff like that. But that's just my 2 cents Understandable. But maybe it could be done anonymously by PMing the admin or something. *shrugs* I dunno, just coming up with stuff. Report
February 7, 200719 yr Author comment_67459 Maybe it's just me but I dont' want to be in the position of "impeaching" someone. That can get ugly fast and cause all kinds of hurt feelings. Not to keep repeating myself but it's too many politics for me on stuff like that. But that's just my 2 cents Staff wouldnt be impeached for little to no reasons, they'd have to do something bad and awful to be impeached. Such as any offical would. SO i doubt anyone would care about feelings if a staff member such as a mod was going around abusing the powers, etc. sometimes its nice for the mods to do that they cannot get away with everything and everything they do has to have a valid reason. On other forums you get banned for looking a certain way, and they don't care because nothing will happen to them if they ban someone. if a staff member bans someone based on something logical such as breaking the rules, harming the community, etc then they wouldn't get in any trouble for that. i want the member base of this forum to have common sense (some other forums lack it) so i think it'd be fine, i dunno i dunno anything today Report
February 7, 200719 yr comment_67461 sometimes its nice for the mods to do that they cannot get away with everything and everything they do has to have a valid reason. On other forums you get banned for looking a certain way, and they don't care because nothing will happen to them if they ban someone. if a staff member bans someone based on something logical such as breaking the rules, harming the community, etc then they wouldn't get in any trouble for that. i want the member base of this forum to have common sense (some other forums lack it) so i think it'd be fine, i dunno i dunno anything today Yeah, exactly. On most forums, people are afraid of the mods, and if that happens, something is wrong. Mods and admins shouldn't be feared; they should be viewed as just regular members with a different colored name. XP And banning powers, but you shouldn't have to worry about being banned if you're not breaking any rules. Some forums don't adhere to that. The biggest thing here is not letting a mod's personal opinion about something get in the way of their interpretation of the forum rules; if it's not in the rules, the admin has the final say. Report
February 8, 200719 yr comment_67488 well the biggest question here is: Is anyone here afraid of the mods?? I mean if the people that are actual mods now were elected to have the positions they have now, then that just says it all. You know well enough then who are the mods who will be jerks/ think they're all that in the future no?! So I don't like the idea of having elections. (This is what I think) Report
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.