Jackson case ground rules on table

This report provided courtesy of
Santa Barbara News-Press

By DAWN HOBBS
NEWS-PRESS STAFF WRITER

A grab bag of motions will be argued in the Michael Jackson case Friday as lawyers attempt to set the ground rules for how the child molestation trial will proceed — including whether the accuser and his brother should testify behind closed doors.

Prosecutors want to prohibit the defense from assaulting the credibility of their witnesses or questioning the district attorney’s motives, the number of search warrants issued or the cost of the investigation.

Defense lawyers want to exclude any mention of their client’s prior civil settlements. They also seek to bar prosecutors from using witness statements about former business associates of Mr. Jackson who are alleged to have been involved in a conspiracy with him but have not been charged.

Superior Court Judge Rodney Melville will hear arguments Friday regarding these matters during one of the last pretrial hearings in the case.

Prosecutors say they want a level playing field, and defense lawyers say they want to make sure their client gets a fair trial, according to dozens of documents filed by both sides and released on the court’s Web site.

Trial is set to begin Monday with jury selection; however, motions may be filed throughout the month it’s expected to take to select a jury.

Mr. Jackson has pleaded not guilty to child molestation and conspiracy charges. The trial is expected to last up to six months.

One of the key motions the judge is scheduled to hear Friday is the prosecution’s request to close the courtroom to the public while the young accuser, 15, and his brother, 14, testify about the molestation that is alleged to have occurred two years ago.

“It is no exaggeration to say that this may be the most reported criminal trial to occur in our lifetimes,” the prosecution’s request stated. “… The defense has announced their desire to destroy any witness who dare to accuse the defendant at trial. … The harm presented to these children by public presentation of their trial testimony would be immeasurable.”

Prosecutors suggest that an audio feed of the testimony be provided to reporters who would be seated in a nearby room. But Theodore Boutrous, a media lawyer who represents several news organizations covering this case, says this won’t do.

“The testimony of both witnesses, especially the alleged victim, is crucial to this case,” Mr. Boutrous stated in his response to the prosecution request. “Their demeanor is a key aspect of the upcoming trial testimony, and the jury’s determination of their credibility will largely determine the outcome. If the public cannot observe these proceedings, a cloud of public doubt will hang over any verdict because the public will have been barred from observing the most important part of the trial.”

In the other motions, most of the information prosecutors and defense lawyers stated they want kept from jurors has already been presented in open court and extensively reported on by the media.

The defense lawyers have repeatedly attacked the credibility of the accuser and his mother. They allege the boy lied to back up similar allegations in an unrelated civil suit and plan to point to that lawsuit to show the mother has a pattern of making up allegations for financial gain.

The lawyers have also accused Santa Barbara County District Attorney Tom Sneddon of “outrageous government conduct” by serving more than 100 search warrants in this case, which is more than even most death penalty cases, they argue.

They’ve claimed the prosecutor has a vendetta against their client because of a 1993 child molestation investigation that crumbled when the accuser in that case accepted a multimillion-dollar settlement from Mr. Jackson in a simultaneous civil suit.

Defense lawyers do not want prosecutors to mention that settlement or another one with a boy who accused Mr. Jackson of inappropriately touching him through his clothing.

These settlements, the defense lawyers say, were made at the advice of Mr. Jackson’s business associates who stood to lose money had he gone through lengthy trials. Not only has Mr. Jackson not admitted to any wrongdoing, but the lawyers point out in their motion that the statute of limitations has expired in those cases.

Prosecutors also want the judge to admit erotic materials seized from Mr. Jackson’s bedroom during law enforcement’s initial raid of Neverland Valley Ranch in November 2003.

The judge will also decide Friday whether to approve the prosecution’s request to put on the stand a forensic accountant, entertainment expert and expert on battered woman’s syndrome. The prosecutors claim testimony from the accountant and entertainment experts will explain the conspiracy part of the allegations and why Mr. Jackson was financially compelled to abduct, falsely imprison and extort the boy and his family until they participated in a video that was intended to rebut a BBC documentary that cast him in a bad light.

The judge will also hear arguments Friday about whether to insist that the British journalist who made that documentary, Martin Bashir, testify as a prosecution witness. “Living with Michael Jackson,” which aired February 2003, showed the boy who would later become his accuser holding hands with the entertainer, who states in the video that he shares his bed with children.

Lawyers for Mr. Bashir have asked the judge to bar prosecutors from calling the journalist to the stand. They argue the California Shield Law grants journalists absolute protection from compelled disclosure of sources or any unpublished information obtained during news gathering.

***

The Santa Barbara County district attorney and sheriff released a statement Monday saying they are not responsible for recent leaks of grand jury transcripts and search warrant documents in the molestation case against Michael Jackson.

“Recently there has been a noticeable increase in the release to the public of highly confidential transcripts, investigative reports and documents about the Michael Jackson case,” District Attorney Tom Sneddon and Sheriff Jim Anderson said in a news release. These materials have been been under seal by order of Superior Court Judge Rodney Melville. “Some media commentators have alleged that we are responsible for these leaks,” the release said. “We are not. These accusations are irresponsible, unfounded and untrue.”

The district attorney and sheriff stated they are investigating the release of the material, which they consider a violation of law.

By DAWN HOBBS
NEWS-PRESS STAFF WRITER

This report provided courtesy of
Santa Barbara News-Press

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x