Judge allows lawyers access to witnesses in Jackson case

This report provided courtesy of Santa Barbara News-Press

By DAWN HOBBS
NEWS-PRESS STAFF WRITER

A judge loosened an order Friday that prohibited witnesses from speaking with anyone after they testified in the secret grand jury proceeding in the child molestation case against Michael Jackson.

The entertainer’s defense team successfully argued their client’s right to effective legal representation had been eroded because the grand jury order kept the lawyers from interviewing their own witnesses.

After the ruling by presiding Superior Court Judge Clifford Anderson, defense attorney Mark Geragos asked that witnesses who have already testified be brought into court and informed of the changes.

Mr. Geragos said witnesses need to hear it from the grand jury foreman because the ultra-secrecy of the proceeding may have them more reticent to speak than is warranted: “If you believe what’s been reported in the paper, witnesses are wrapped up in blankets like they’re Osama bin Laden’s lieutenants” and whisked into the grand jury proceeding and then “spirited back out.”

Although the judge loosened the “decorum” order for the defense, he declined to lift the veil of secrecy that has shrouded this case any further. Judge Anderson denied media access to grand jury witnesses, related hearings and sealed documents. He noted the high-profile case is wrought with conflicting rights:

“We have the defendant’s right to effective counsel…. The victim’s right to privacy. And we have people wearing the hat of the media asserting their First Amendment right to have access to public hearings. Then we have the rights of the people conducting the grand jury hearing to conduct it in private. We have a clash of rights.”

The judge ruled the right to grand jury secrecy supersedes the media’s right to access.

Media attorney Theodore Boutrous argued witnesses shouldn’t be “smuggled” into the grand jury hearing to protect their identity. “We know there are sensitive issues here, but this is going too far.”

Senior Deputy District Attorney Gerald Franklin told Mr. Boutrous he was “mistaken” and that prosecutors may “smuggle witnesses into the grand jury room and back out and keep the watch-dog press removed from the location.”

Mr. Jackson’s defense team sided with the prosecution on media access. “The media will have access to the information at an appropriate time and to do so before the appropriate time would highly prejudice the proceedings,” said Ben Brafman, assisted by co-counsel Robert Sanger and Steve Cochrane.

The grand jury is expected to meet for the 11th day Monday in the proceedings against Mr. Jackson. He faces seven counts of lewd conduct with a child and two counts of administering alcohol to commit the alleged molestation.

This report provided courtesy of Santa Barbara News-Press

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x